Get Apps
Get Apps
Get Apps
點新聞-dotdotnews
Through dots,we connect.

Opinion | Shortcomings in US electoral system: Election, or combat?

Opinion
2024.11.05 14:40
X
Wechat
Weibo

By Zhou Dewu

November 5 marks the final voting day for the US presidential election. As of 9 am Eastern Time on Nov. 3, over 78 million voters had already cast their ballots early, resulting in an overall turnout exceeding 50%. However, the final outcome of the election largely depends on the overall turnout and the gender ratio of voters. This election is a contest between male and female candidates and a showdown between male and female voters. In a sense, the Democratic Party is becoming the "women's party," while the Republican Party is evolving into the "men's party." The Chinese phrase "Women can hold up half the sky" is particularly relevant in the context of the current US election.

This US election has been chaotic, exposing significant flaws in the American electoral system.

First, the primary election mechanism of the two major parties is problematic. The combined age of the candidates from the Democratic and Republican parties exceeds 160 years. These elderly candidates, who should be enjoying their twilight years, have chosen to "push their limits." Although younger Republican figures like DeSantis and Haley intended to challenge Trump, they ultimately fell short. Biden's poor performance during the first presidential debate on June 27 led Democratic leaders to "pressure" him to step aside, treating the primary voting process as a farce. While Democrats repeatedly blamed Trump for his unwillingness to concede power peacefully in January 2021, they themselves engaged in what many Republicans consider "anti-democratic" practices during the primaries, undoubtedly weakening the Democratic narrative of democracy.

Trump has accused the Democrats of manipulating the 2020 election. In October of that year, the FBI suppressed the laptop scandal involving Biden's son Hunter, citing Russian interference in the election. The anticipated October surprise failed to materialize, which incensed Trump and his supporters, further entrenching beliefs in election fraud and conspiracy theories.

Second, the election highlights significant loopholes in the US Constitution. The Founding Fathers were too simplistic in establishing the criteria for presidential candidates.

The fact that a figure like Trump, with a controversial past, can run for president is exceedingly rare in American history. It seems the Constitution's framers did not anticipate that the moral baseline for American voters could sink to such lows. The phenomenon of "bad money driving out good" is vividly illustrated in this election. Former First Lady Michelle Obama remarked in 2016 that while Trump pursued low standards, they must pursue high standards. Yet, eight years later, both parties have abandoned high standards, and personal attacks have intensified.

Trump has called Harris "stupid" and "dumb as a rock," referring to her as a "shit vice president." In turn, Harris has accused Trump of being self-centered and unserious, stating that the consequences of elevating such a person to the presidency are "extremely serious."

Third, this election has intensified the competition between the establishment, represented by the Democratic Party, and the anti-establishment factions. Compared to 2016, some establishment Republicans have rallied around Trump, but many remain firmly in the "Never Trump" camp. Notably, Barbara Bush, daughter of former Republican President George W. Bush, and Liz Cheney, daughter of former Vice President Dick Cheney, have publicly supported Harris. Trump's former allies have voiced their belief that he is unfit to return to the White House, arguing that his attention span is less than five minutes, and he behaves irresponsibly, showing minimal patience during briefings. However, Trump's supporters remain unfazed, firmly believing he can save America, highlighting American voters' division and distrust of the existing system.

Fourth, this election challenges the "wealth effect" theory. Many believe that a booming stock market equates to overall prosperity; however, the importance of sharing economic gains is even more critical. During the 2020 election, Trump claimed that the US stock market would implode if Biden were elected. When Biden was inaugurated on January 20, 2021, the Dow Jones Industrial Average stood at 30,000 points, soaring to over 42,000 points by November 3 of this year—a remarkable increase, with the stock market achieving historical highs during Biden's presidency. Statistics show that 58% of American households own stocks and other assets, and traditional theory suggests that a rising market would enhance the "wealth effect," leading to improved conditions for voters. Yet, the inflation rate has outpaced income growth, causing even the middle class to feel financial pressure. More importantly, 42% of households do not own stocks, missing market gains and facing even harsher economic realities.

Multiple polls indicate that two-thirds of Americans believe the economy under Biden is performing poorly, while only one-third feel it is doing well. Last week, at a rally in New York's Madison Square Garden, Trump asked his supporters, "Are you better off than you were four years ago?" The crowd resoundingly responded, "No!" In Trump's final year in office, the US government swiftly implemented a US$2 trillion emergency relief package in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. After Biden took office, he followed suit, leading to inflation rates peaking at 9.1%. Ultimately, the Federal Reserve had to take drastic measures, significantly raising interest rates, which had evident side effects.

As interest rates soared, mortgage rates followed suit, leading to widespread discontent among the public. This situation stems from Biden's economic policies and represents a heavy burden for Harris. How much this will affect her electoral prospects will soon be revealed.

However, one thing is certain: whether Harris or Trump takes office, the overall policy direction in the US will lean conservative, as evidenced by Harris's rightward shift in policies.

(Source: Ta Kung Pao)

Related News:

Opinion | Battle between genders: Who's worse in US presidential election?

Opinion | The defining moment of 2024 is here

Tag:·electoral system· moral baseline· financial pressure· interest rates· presidential election

Comment

Opinion
More >>
Opinion | An open letter to Cambridge University: Have we misplaced our trust in IELTS? This article questions the effectiveness of IELTS as a measure of English proficiency, arguing that high scores do not necessarily reflect students' ability to communicate or perform academically. It criticizes the test's emphasis on exam techniques, obscure reading materials and time-pressured tasks, which may disadvantage candidates without improving their practical language skills.
Philip Yeung
2026.10.19 11:22
Opinion | China-Philippines tensions: Selective listening when a statement of restraint becomes a summons The article argues that Philippine officials have selectively interpreted Chinese Ambassador Jing Quan's remarks by focusing on his reference to China's military capabilities while overlooking his stated commitment to peace. It criticizes Manila's approach to South China Sea disputes and examines how US-Philippines military cooperation may further heighten regional tensions.
Angelo Giuliano
2026.10.18 19:35
Opinion | HK retains its crown as world's freest economy: Open-market strengths endure and 'one country, two systems' dividend persists The Fraser Institute of Canada released its Economic Freedom of the World 2026 Annual Report on 6 October 2026. Hong Kong has once again been named the world's freest economy among 165 economies, with an overall score of 8.53. Since the Report was first published in 1996, Hong Kong has consistently ranked first—clear evidence that, whatever changes the external environment may bring, the core competitiveness of Hong Kong as a free economy continues to stand the test of time and of international assessment.
Kevin Lau
2026.10.18 12:35
Opinion | 'Building Bridges'- How North Korea went from isolated pariah to strategic counterweight Since 2014, a "new" bridge has stood on the Yalu River between Dandong in China and Sinuiju in North Korea. This massive white spired bridge, built by Chinese engineering, was intended to deepen economic integration between the two Communist neighbours, having previously relied on the very small, Japanese Imperial-derived railway bridge known as the "Sino-Korean Friendship Bridge." The new bridge was thus to be revolutionary, yet for reasons entirely related to the North Korean side, it didn't open.
Tom Fowdy
2026.10.16 14:00
Deepline
More >>
Deepline | Canton Fair: HK's 'super-connector' role helps mainland exporters win overseas orders The 140th Canton Fair opened in Guangzhou on Oct. 15, with Hong Kong leveraging its role as a "super connector" to help mainland exporters secure overseas orders, enter emerging markets and expand global R&D. Companies cited Hong Kong's international networks, innovation ecosystem and financial and aviation hubs as key advantages.
Deepline
2026.10.16 11:13
Deepline | Shenzhen, HK step up preparations for APEC 2026 with enhanced connectivity and services Shenzhen and Hong Kong are stepping up preparations for the 2026 APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting on Nov. 18-19, with upgraded transport links, cross-border data cooperation, improved payment services and multilingual support for overseas visitors. Shenzhen's trade with other APEC economies reached RMB 1.98 trillion in the first half of 2026, accounting for nearly 70% of its total foreign trade.
Deepline
2026.10.15 15:31
Deepline | 1 in 10 claim social benefits: US media says welfare system is crushing Britain Ahead of UK Chancellor Healey's first budget for the Burnham government, Britain's troubled welfare system has once again become a media focus. The Wall Street Journal said in an article on the 11th that the UK's welfare system is "crushing" the country.
Deepline
2026.10.14 17:30
Deepline | HK attracts global fashion names as KIM JONES picks city for first flagship store Hong Kong's unique role as a gateway connecting the Chinese mainland with the rest of the world is making it a preferred destination for international brands seeking to expand their presence in Asia. KIM JONES, the eponymous fashion label founded by renowned British designer Kim Jones OBE, is set to open its first-ever retail flagship store in HK in the second half of 2027, signalling international brands' confidence in the city's core commercial districts, consumer spending power and role as a global gateway.
Deepline
2026.10.14 13:35
World
More >>
Priest killed as large wooden crucifix falls during Mass in Ecuador A Catholic priest in Ecuador was killed on Oct 17 after a large wooden crucifix mounted behind him broke loose and fell forward while he was celebrating Mass, in an incident captured during a live broadcast, according to The Standard.
World
2026.10.19 13:21
Opinion | An open letter to Cambridge University: Have we misplaced our trust in IELTS? This article questions the effectiveness of IELTS as a measure of English proficiency, arguing that high scores do not necessarily reflect students' ability to communicate or perform academically. It criticizes the test's emphasis on exam techniques, obscure reading materials and time-pressured tasks, which may disadvantage candidates without improving their practical language skills.
Philip Yeung
2026.10.19 11:22
Opinion | China-Philippines tensions: Selective listening when a statement of restraint becomes a summons The article argues that Philippine officials have selectively interpreted Chinese Ambassador Jing Quan's remarks by focusing on his reference to China's military capabilities while overlooking his stated commitment to peace. It criticizes Manila's approach to South China Sea disputes and examines how US-Philippines military cooperation may further heighten regional tensions.
Angelo Giuliano
2026.10.18 19:35
Japan considers corporate tax hike to fund soaring defence spending Japan is considering raising corporate taxes to help fund a major increase in defence spending as the government moves to revise its three key national security and defence policy documents, Kyodo News reported exclusively on Oct. 17, citing multiple sources familiar with the matter. Under the proposal being discussed within the Japanese government, higher corporate income tax would provide a stable source of funding for the country's continued military expansion.
World
2026.10.18 18:21
More
More >>
Caricature: Allied trade tensions grow as EU weighs risks of becoming Washington's next target The United States has escalated a tariff dispute with Canada, triggering fresh concerns over trade tensions among close Western allies and adding pressure on partners that could be caught in the crossfire.
Dot Dot Pic
2026.09.27 18:10
Journalist's View | He gives a thumbs-up 'you are in great spirits': Truly understand what it means to stand with HK I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve met the Chief Executive, John Lee.
Editors' Pick
2026.09.18 15:55
Journalist's Hands-on Experience | On the road to Xizang's disaster zone A reporter travels from Dingri County to the front line of the landslide-hit Gyirong Port in Xizang, witnessing rescue vehicles rushing through rain and fog after National Highway 216 was largely reopened. Along the 260-kilometer journey, the reporter speaks with local residents and rescue workers about worsening weather, helicopter operations and ongoing search-and-rescue efforts, before reaching the junction of National Highway 216, where access remains restricted to rescue vehicles.
Editors' Pick
2026.09.03 12:13
Journalist's View | There's no such thing as a 'Caotai Team' — It's just another way to encourage innovation On May 25, Chinese novelist Yu Hua posted a short video on social media titled "What Is a Caotai Team?" In the clip, Yu and three very different people shared their stories: a 16-year-old middle school student who taught himself documentary filmmaking; a food delivery rider who has been delivering for eight years while writing for 38 years and is now known as a "delivery poet"; and a young man from a small town who builds model airplanes by hand.
Editors' Pick
2026.05.29 19:06
Click for more
< Go back
Search Content 
Content
Title
Keyword
New to old 
New to old
Old to new
Relativity
No Result found
No more
Close
Light Dark