By Eunice Yung
After the Wang Fuk Court fire, Hong Kong must rebuild what failed, for the people who will carry this loss all their lives.
For the city, the Wang Fuk Court fire was a tragedy on one November afternoon. For the families, it never ended. A hundred and sixty-eight people died, from a baby of seven months to a woman of 98, and Senior Fireman Ho Wai-ho gave his life trying to save others. Nearly 2,000 households lost their homes, and thousands of residents now live scattered across temporary housing. They will live with this loss every day for the rest of their lives. No compensation can give back what home meant, or the people who are gone.
That is why the independent committee's report matters. It cannot undo the loss, but it can ensure that the loss changes how Hong Kong protects its people.
What the Report Tells Us
The committee led by Justice David Lok spent months on its work, holding 30 hearing days, hearing 80 witnesses and reviewing more than a million files. Its findings are candid, and the public should accept them.
The report concludes that the fire was most likely started by a cigarette igniting debris, and that human failures turned a small fire into a disaster. The renovation used non-fire-retardant nets and canvas, and foam boards covered windows for about 15 months. Openings cut into escape staircases let smoke in, and the fire alarms had been switched off. The committee named the main contractor and the consultant as the main culprits, citing deliberate corner-cutting and a "dummy" inspector who signed documents without doing the work.
The report is equally direct about government. It finds that the Buildings Department, the Independent Checking Unit, the Fire Services Department and the Labour Department each fell short. The Buildings Department and the Independent Checking Unit were the two bodies primarily responsible for supervising the works, and the unit was found to bear the greater share of the two. Inspections were announced in advance, certificates were accepted without verification, and residents' complaints were passed between desks until they "fell into a vacuum". The report also found that bid-rigging in large renovation tenders is widespread and long-standing, with triad involvement in some cases.
It is to the government's credit that it published these findings without euphemism. A system can only be repaired once it is honestly examined. The committee also offered a fair reminder that its criticisms do not apply to the civil service as a whole, and that many public servants work diligently every day.
Acting Before the Report Arrived
Past inquiries have often been followed by a long wait, with remedies held back until the final findings. The committee noted this tradition, then welcomed the fact that the Hong Kong SAR government did not follow it, saying such speed should be commended as an indication of good governance.
Many reforms were already under way. The Buildings Department now requires protective nets to be randomly sampled and tested by accredited laboratories, and nets were ordered removed from some 230 private buildings after fraudulent certificates were found. Foam boards and other combustible materials are barred from windows and external walls. A comprehensive smoking ban on construction sites took effect on July 17, closing a legal gap that had left inspectors with little power over the likely cause of the fire.
The Fire Services Department has raised emergency call lines from 30 to 68, moved fire installation certificates onto a digital platform with QR codes anyone can verify, and sealed the master switches whose shutdown silenced the alarms. The Emergency Alert System can now target specific localities. The Independent Checking Unit has ended pre-announced inspections. For homeowners, funds have been set aside for an enhanced support service for building repairs, and pre-qualified lists of consultants and contractors, screened by the police and the Independent Commission Against Corruption, are due to begin appearing from the end of this year.
Taking Responsibility
The chief executive's response after the report's release on Oct 29 also deserves understanding. He led senior officials in a bow of apology and accepted the resignation of the Secretary for Housing, Winnie Ho, who stepped down to take political responsibility for the shortcomings the report identified. No personal wrongdoing was found, which makes her decision to take responsibility at the top all the more significant. Those in charge should answer for failures that occur on their watch.
This is one part of a broader framework. Criminal proceedings against seven individuals and two companies continue. A two-tier Head of Department Responsibility mechanism will examine the conduct of 40 to 50 civil servants, from junior ranks to department heads, with a three-month deadline. Together, these steps cover the political, administrative and criminal dimensions of accountability.
Some residents have said the apology came late. That is an honest feeling, and those who have borne the pain are entitled to it. The best reply is visible, sustained work.
From Report to Delivery
That work now has an owner. Chief Secretary for Administration Eric Chan Kwok-ki will lead an inter-departmental steering committee, expected to hold its first meeting in November, to oversee the roughly 120 recommendations. Each department must submit specific plans and timetables, and where a recommendation crosses departmental lines, a lead agency will be named. Mr Chan has set three principles of being rigorous, swift and effective, and expects most recommendations to be fully carried out within months.
Legislation is moving in step. Six ordinances, including those on fire services, property management and competition, are being amended, with drafts due before the Legislative Council before the year ends. The plan to treat bid-rigging in large building works as a serious crime, with stronger investigative powers, the ability to freeze assets, and heavier penalties, goes to the root of how unscrupulous operators came to control a HK$336 million project. A central database, due to launch its first phase around May or June next year, will bring together inspection, penalty, violation, conviction and complaint records from the Fire Services, Labour and Buildings departments, so that a contractor's record in one office is visible in all.
Beyond laws and databases lies attitude. The committee urged a more people-centered civil service that takes "an extra step" for citizens, and Mr Chan has embraced the idea, promising to build it into civil service training. Residents raised their concerns repeatedly before the fire. A public service that listens, shares information and treats every warning as potentially a matter of life and death is the surest way to honor them.
Keeping Faith
The fire is out, but for the families it is not over, and it will not be for a long time. Money, rehousing and official apologies cannot return what was taken. All they can do is show the families that they are not alone.
The Hong Kong SAR government has shown the determination to establish the facts, hold people accountable and change a system that failed, and it acted swiftly. Carrying the work through to the end, and reporting on it openly, is the only way to give the families' loss a meaning that lasts. Regular public updates on the steering committee's progress would let citizens see for themselves whether promises are becoming practice.
The report cannot undo the loss, and no reform will ever be enough to answer it. But the 168, and the families who remain, are owed a city that has truly changed.
The views do not necessarily reflect those of DotDotNews.
Related News:
Opinion | Accountability and reform with determination: A united effort to safeguard building safety
Comment