Get Apps
Get Apps
Get Apps
點新聞-dotdotnews
Through dots,we connect.

Opinion | India's dilemma: To befriend the U.S. or mend fence with China

Augustus K. Yeung
2023.06.28 17:56
X
Wechat
Weibo

By Augustus K. Yeung

INTRODUCTION

What Indian PM Narendra Modi did in the US Congress joint welcome session was street smart, not a work of wisdom. Some critics said he seemed to be more "appealing to the voters back in India" than anything else, keeping in mind the next election.

What stunt did he pull?

Modi put together the initials of two countries, America and India, and came out with an acronym AI, to mean "artificial intelligence", winning applauses from the audience, many of them are lawmakers. They were here with the White House officials for various purposes: To counter a rising China; and for Joe Biden, to show that he can unite the two rival parties at a time when Trump is "posturing the stance of a president" as one New York Times journalist put it.

Biden might also want to lure Modi into a rope round his neck – to counter, contain and consume China, whenever necessity demands.

To achieve these current and distant goals, Washington has gone out of its way to please Modi by rolling out the red carpet, setting a state banquet and even offering to share with him its prized "jet engine" technology.

What about Modi's ethnic issues in India? How can the theatrical shows staged by the White House and the US Congress help PM Modi to solve his domestic problems and the Himalayan border issue with China?

The following excerpt will jog our memory concerning Modi's headaches.

Modi has been trying to strengthen India's hard power…

Meanwhile, Modi has been trying to enhance India's hard power. Capital spending on defense has been increasing since he came to power. In the 2023-24 budget announced in February, India allocated 13 per cent more funds to the defense sector than in the previous year.

Some of India's expenditure on defense has already borne fruit. This month, the navy put on display a new indigenous aircraft carrier, which should become fully operational later this year, in an exercise involving more than 35 aircraft, Modi now hopes to sign a deal with the US to co-produce jet engines for Indian fighter aircraft.

Yet, despite this incremental progress, India's military forces remain heavily overburdened. Notwithstanding increased spending, India's defense sector has suffered a massive shortfall between funds allocated and the military's need over the past five years. There are concerns the country's naval fleet is reaching obsolescence and that the strength of the air force's fighter squadrons is declining.

The military's needs, however, are only burgeoning with time. Despite negotiations with China following the deadly border clash in 2020, India now anticipates a permanently heavy deployment on the disputed border.

With ongoing political instability in Pakistan, there are also worries about spillovers on the western front, where militants have previously exploited political chaos at home to carry out cross-border attacks in India.

Recent events have shown that troubles can deplete India's overstretched military resources…

Recent events have also shown that troubles at home have the potential to further deplete India's already thinly stretched military resources. Take the northeastern state of Manipur, for instance.

After horrifying ethnic clashes broke out there early last month and local police force proved inadequate, the military was called in to control the violence. Nearly 40,000 security personnel have been stationed in Manipur, according to one report, including any army division whose primary role is to serve as a reserve formation for the border with China.

With no political solution in sight, there is a danger that the Indian army may end up with a substantial long-term deployment there.

Meanwhile, tens of thousands of army troops have been stationed in Kashmir – one of the world's most heavily militarized regions – after Delhi controversially stripped the state of Jammu and Kashmir of its semi-autonomous status in 2019.

While the Modi government is reportedly pondering the withdrawal of these troops from Kashmir's hinterland to be replaced by the Central Reserve Police Force, many remain concerned over the resulting potential for instability in the past few years. Kashmir has seen multiple episodes of violence against police, government employees and the Hindu minority.

There have also been sporadic outbreaks of violence in other parts of India in recent years, as communal tensions remain high between Hindu and Muslims. In March, violence broke out in multiple states during religious processions. Such episodes will keep India's security apparatus on edge and raise pressure on its military because of the threat of further deployment. (Source: SCMP)

CONCLUSION

With Asia's security landscape becoming potentially more volatile, there are developments that should worry India, the U.S. and China. A likely scenario may result in Washington for treating India as a key security partner in Asia.

Over the past several months, Washington appears to be more focused on its defense ties with Japan, South Korea, Australia and the Philippines. This month, Japan joined NATO's largest air force drill in Germany.

The US may also want to draw India into its sphere of influence or orbit by sharing its advanced defense technology with Delhi – one of Modi's key priorities in the relationship

However, in recent years, there has been criticism in Washington of India's internal politics. Shortly before the state visit, 75 U.S. Senators sent a joint letter to the president, condemning Modi's human rights violation records.

Washington believes India's military is too distracted by threats at home, and Biden may have solicited cooperation from the US Congress for support now, and for a defense pact with India in the future.

For Modi, this ought to spark concern. Unless India can manage domestic stability, and eschew divisive communal rhetoric in politics, Delhi might find itself weakened and marginalized in Asia's evolving geopolitical landscape. Notably, its long-lasting challenging border issue with China.

Will all these partying in Washington as well as bathing in its limelight and music help Narendra Modi solve his headaches back home, not to mention raising India's international profile?

 

The views do not necessarily reflect those of DotDotNews.

Read more articles by Augustus K. Yeung:

Opinion | If the Chinese leader were a 'dictator,' he's a 'benevolent dictator'

Opinion | As U.S. sets out terms for ceasefire, China's peace initiative is gathering momentum

Tag:·opinion· Augustus· dilemma· U.S.· China· fence

Comment

Video
More >>
Ningboese Lineage in HK | Rule of law as bridge for Ningbo-Hong Kong cooperation: Rita Fan's unwavering devotion to hometown DotDotNews' special feature, "Ningboese Lineage in HK," interviewed Rita Fan Hsu Lai-tai, a Hong Kong resident of Ningbo origin, the first President of the HKSAR Legislative Council, and a Council Member of the Endeavour Education Centre, along with her son Andrew Fan Chun-wah. The feature explores the profound bond between Ningbo and Hong Kong through their perspective and examines future collaboration opportunities between the two regions.
Video
2026.10.15 11:23
100 Ways To Drool | Egg-baked pancake The egg-baked pancake is a traditional street snack from Chengdu, Sichuan Province, China.
100 Ways To Drool
2026.10.14 17:40
Ningboese Lineage in HK | Chao Kuang-piu family's deep dive into tech innovation ignites a new engine for Ningbo-HK synergy The Chao family, a prominent Hong Kong family of Ningbo origin, has played a significant role in advancing industrial development and technological innovation in the Chinese mainland. The family's legacy reflects the pioneering spirit of Ningbo merchants and highlights opportunities for stronger Ningbo-Hong Kong collaboration in technological innovation and industrial upgrading.
Video
2026.10.14 11:30
OMG | What does school lunch look like in China? School lunches — a daily ritual for millions of students across China. But what does it actually look like on the ground? The rice falls off the spoon two seconds after being placed in the bowl. Each student can choose their own portion size. We take you inside Chinese school canteens to see how lunchtime really works. Let's take a look!
OMG
2026.10.14 09:35
Opinion
More >>
Opinion | Behind the double 'World's No. 1': How world-class hospitality is forging a new chapter for HK tourism Bar Leone in Central, Hong Kong, was crowned the world's best bar for the second consecutive year. Barely three weeks earlier, Rosewood Hong Kong likewise retained its No. 1 ranking, becoming the only hotel to successfully defend the title since the list was founded. Bars and hotels are two mirrors of the hospitality industry. That both "world's best" titles have fallen to Hong Kong in the same year is no coincidence—it is an objective affirmation by international professional juries of the city's service standards and business environment.
Kevin Lau
2026.10.15 09:25
Opinion | Here's what Trump's Russian diesel ploy is all about US President Donald Trump has provoked outrage by announcing a plan to import diesel from the Russian Federation. The plan, widely condemned by allies and other American politicians, is a slap in the face to the massive sanctions imposed on Moscow by Washington following its invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
Tom Fowdy
2026.10.14 18:00
Opinion | Asian Games: HK demonstrates its prowess Tony Kwok says city's success demonstrates merits of the "one country, two systems" policy
Opinion
2026.10.11 10:53
Opinion | Nobel Peace Prize—Denied twice, will Trump start another war? Once again, Trump the warmonger, misses out on the Nobel Peace Prize. That leaves him hopping mad. He calls the decision to give the award to Navi Pillay, a former UN human rights chief "disgraceful and embarrassing". I shudder to think what Trump will do next year when the big bad bully is denied his coveted prize a third time. Will he go berserk, and start another war just to spite Norway? With Trump, nothing is too far-fetched.
Philip Yeung
2026.10.10 20:15
Deepline
More >>
Deepline | Shenzhen, HK step up preparations for APEC 2026 with enhanced connectivity and services Shenzhen and Hong Kong are stepping up preparations for the 2026 APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting on Nov. 18-19, with upgraded transport links, cross-border data cooperation, improved payment services and multilingual support for overseas visitors. Shenzhen's trade with other APEC economies reached RMB 1.98 trillion in the first half of 2026, accounting for nearly 70% of its total foreign trade.
Deepline
2026.10.15 15:31
Deepline | 1 in 10 claim social benefits: US media says welfare system is crushing Britain Ahead of UK Chancellor Healey's first budget for the Burnham government, Britain's troubled welfare system has once again become a media focus. The Wall Street Journal said in an article on the 11th that the UK's welfare system is "crushing" the country.
Deepline
2026.10.14 17:30
Deepline | HK attracts global fashion names as KIM JONES picks city for first flagship store Hong Kong's unique role as a gateway connecting the Chinese mainland with the rest of the world is making it a preferred destination for international brands seeking to expand their presence in Asia. KIM JONES, the eponymous fashion label founded by renowned British designer Kim Jones OBE, is set to open its first-ever retail flagship store in HK in the second half of 2027, signalling international brands' confidence in the city's core commercial districts, consumer spending power and role as a global gateway.
Deepline
2026.10.14 13:35
Deepline | Chinese innovation and engineering take center stage at the Aichi-Nagoya Asian Games The Aichi-Nagoya Asian Games came to a close on Oct. 4 after a two-week competition, with China topping the gold medal table for the 12th consecutive edition.
Deepline
2026.10.08 18:05
Hong Kong
More >>
Jointly organised by Jao Tsung-l Academy and Sun Museum: 4 young artists infuse Chinese cultural heritage into contemporary art "Hong Kong Emerging Artists Exhibition" Phase 5 officially opens today at Jao Tsung-l Academy.
Lifestyle
2026.10.15 20:19
Typhoon Champi could intensify into super typhoon, take sharp turn towards Japan Typhoon Champi, the 30th typhoon of the year, formed on Thursday (Oct. 15) and is gradually strengthening, with its maximum intensity potentially reaching super typhoon status. The Hong Kong Observatory forecasts that the tropical cyclone over the northwestern Pacific will gradually intensify over the next two to three days as it passes near Guam. It is expected to move towards waters east of Luzon in the early to middle part of next week.
Hong Kong
2026.10.15 18:12
Watch This | SailGP to make HK debut in Victoria Harbour in January, tickets on sale Oct. 27 The inaugural American Express Hong Kong Sail Grand Prix will take place on Jan. 23-24, 2027, bringing the Rolex SailGP Championship to Victoria Harbour for the first time. Races will be staged near the Kai Tak Cruise Terminal, with general ticket sales opening on Oct. 27 and priority booking for eligible American Express Cardmembers starting Oct. 21.
Hong Kong
2026.10.15 17:31
Baidu's Apollo Go to offer free robotaxi rides in HK from Oct. 21 Baidu's Apollo Go will launch its first public autonomous vehicle trial in Hong Kong's Tung Chung from Oct. 21 to Nov. 3, offering 14 days of free rides. Tickets will be distributed by district offices from Oct. 16, with each trip covering about 5.1 km and taking approximately 15 minutes.
Hong Kong
2026.10.15 16:26
China
More >>
Zheng Qinwen confirms second consecutive withdrawal Zheng Qinwen, China's top tennis player, has confirmed her withdrawal from the WTA250 Osaka tournament scheduled for next week. This marks the second consecutive event she has pulled out of, following her withdrawal from the Wuhan Open. Her remaining schedule for the season includes the qualifying rounds of the WTA500 Tokyo event and the WTA250 Hong Kong tournament.
China
2026.10.15 20:05
70 years on, China's Canton Fair highlights innovation, intelligence in global trade The 140th edition of the China Import and Export Fair, also known as the Canton Fair, opened to visitors in Guangzhou, capital of south China's Guangdong Province on Thursday (Oct. 15), with more than 30,000 exhibiting companies and about 340,000 overseas buyers expected to attend.
China
2026.10.15 19:25
Deepline | Shenzhen, HK step up preparations for APEC 2026 with enhanced connectivity and services Shenzhen and Hong Kong are stepping up preparations for the 2026 APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting on Nov. 18-19, with upgraded transport links, cross-border data cooperation, improved payment services and multilingual support for overseas visitors. Shenzhen's trade with other APEC economies reached RMB 1.98 trillion in the first half of 2026, accounting for nearly 70% of its total foreign trade.
Deepline
2026.10.15 15:31
New China-DPRK border bridge over Yalu River opens today The New China-DPRK border bridge over the Yalu River, located in Dandong, Liaoning Province, opened to traffic in both directions today (Oct. 15). At approximately 10:34 am, ten vehicles on the Chinese side sounded their horns in unison and slowly drove towards the North Korean border gate, which was adorned with giant national flags of both countries. This marks the official opening of the new Yalu River Bridge, which has been in operation for 12 years.
China
2026.10.15 13:00
World
More >>
Zheng Qinwen confirms second consecutive withdrawal Zheng Qinwen, China's top tennis player, has confirmed her withdrawal from the WTA250 Osaka tournament scheduled for next week. This marks the second consecutive event she has pulled out of, following her withdrawal from the Wuhan Open. Her remaining schedule for the season includes the qualifying rounds of the WTA500 Tokyo event and the WTA250 Hong Kong tournament.
China
2026.10.15 20:05
Watch This | 727 buildings completely collapsed! 7.6-magnitude earthquake in Panama leaves 1 dead and 27 injured Panamanian authorities said on Oct. 14 that a 68-year-old woman who was seriously injured in an earthquake had died. Twenty-seven people sustained minor injuries.
World
2026.10.15 14:02
New China-DPRK border bridge over Yalu River opens today The New China-DPRK border bridge over the Yalu River, located in Dandong, Liaoning Province, opened to traffic in both directions today (Oct. 15). At approximately 10:34 am, ten vehicles on the Chinese side sounded their horns in unison and slowly drove towards the North Korean border gate, which was adorned with giant national flags of both countries. This marks the official opening of the new Yalu River Bridge, which has been in operation for 12 years.
China
2026.10.15 13:00
Netflix to cut 1,000 jobs as shares shed over 20% this year US streaming giant Netflix announced on Oct. 14 that it would cut about 1,000 jobs, or roughly 6% of its global workforce, marking its largest round of layoffs since 2022.
World
2026.10.15 10:18
More
More >>
Caricature: Allied trade tensions grow as EU weighs risks of becoming Washington's next target The United States has escalated a tariff dispute with Canada, triggering fresh concerns over trade tensions among close Western allies and adding pressure on partners that could be caught in the crossfire.
Dot Dot Pic
2026.09.27 18:10
Journalist's View | He gives a thumbs-up 'you are in great spirits': Truly understand what it means to stand with HK I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve met the Chief Executive, John Lee.
Editors' Pick
2026.09.18 15:55
Journalist's Hands-on Experience | On the road to Xizang's disaster zone A reporter travels from Dingri County to the front line of the landslide-hit Gyirong Port in Xizang, witnessing rescue vehicles rushing through rain and fog after National Highway 216 was largely reopened. Along the 260-kilometer journey, the reporter speaks with local residents and rescue workers about worsening weather, helicopter operations and ongoing search-and-rescue efforts, before reaching the junction of National Highway 216, where access remains restricted to rescue vehicles.
Editors' Pick
2026.09.03 12:13
Journalist's View | There's no such thing as a 'Caotai Team' — It's just another way to encourage innovation On May 25, Chinese novelist Yu Hua posted a short video on social media titled "What Is a Caotai Team?" In the clip, Yu and three very different people shared their stories: a 16-year-old middle school student who taught himself documentary filmmaking; a food delivery rider who has been delivering for eight years while writing for 38 years and is now known as a "delivery poet"; and a young man from a small town who builds model airplanes by hand.
Editors' Pick
2026.05.29 19:06
Click for more
< Go back
Search Content 
Content
Title
Keyword
New to old 
New to old
Old to new
Relativity
No Result found
No more
Close
Light Dark