By Angelo Giuliano
The Core Doctrine of Sabbateanism
Sabbatai Zevi, the 17th-century Kabbalist from Smyrna, proclaimed himself the Messiah in 1665, unleashing a massive wave of messianic expectation across Jewish communities worldwide. His prophet, Nathan of Gaza, developed the radical theology known as "redemption through sin" (mitzvah ha-ba'ah ba-averah). Rooted in Lurianic Kabbalah's idea of divine sparks trapped in impure shells (qlippot), this doctrine held that ordinary observance redeems sparks from permissible realms, but ultimate cosmic repair requires the Messiah—and his followers—to deliberately descend into evil. Sinful acts, when performed with messianic purpose, become holy necessities: violating taboos, breaking laws, and embracing impurity hasten true redemption. Zevi's erratic transgressions (eating forbidden foods, pronouncing sacred names, sexual irregularities) were reframed as sacred descents. His 1666 conversion to Islam under Ottoman duress was interpreted by loyalists as the pinnacle of this path—the Messiah entering the deepest qlippah to complete the work.
The Persistence Through Crisis and Sectarian Evolution
Zevi's apostasy shattered the mass movement, but the ideology endured in secretive forms. Believers reinterpreted betrayal as fulfillment, sustaining faith through paradox: the greater the sin, the closer to salvation. In the 18th century, Jacob Frank radicalized this further, claiming to be Zevi's reincarnation. Frank preached total moral inversion—all laws must collapse for redemption. His followers engaged in ritualized sexual libertinism: orgies, incest, wife-swapping—acts performed as deliberate "strange acts" to shatter boundaries and liberate divine light from evil. Frank orchestrated mass conversions to Catholicism while preserving inner heresy, allowing infiltration of the dominant society. Small sects like the Dönmeh (outwardly Muslim) and Frankist circles persisted for generations, blending outward conformity with antinomian beliefs. This created a hidden continuity: a sick ideology that valorized decadence as redemptive, turning moral decay into a spiritual engine.
Epstein's Network as a Modern Echo of Decadence
Jeffrey Epstein's documented criminal enterprise exhibited striking structural parallels to this historical pattern of organized transgression within elite circles. From the 2005 Palm Beach investigation through his 2019 federal charges, Epstein orchestrated a systematic sex-trafficking operation targeting underage girls and young women. Recruitment involved payments for sexual acts and incentives to bring others, forming a pyramid of exploitation. Hidden cameras in his properties (New York townhouse, Palm Beach mansion, Little St. James island) allegedly captured compromising material. The 2008 non-prosecution agreement granted broad immunity, enabling continued elite associations despite conviction. Ghislaine Maxwell's 2021 conviction confirmed grooming and abuse on a large scale, with victims numbering in the dozens to over a thousand per some estimates. Epstein's prolonged impunity stemmed from wealth, connections, and institutional failures.
Parallels in Seeking "Redemption" Through Moral Descent
The deepest parallel lies in the inversion of morality: transgression reframed as a pathway to higher ends. In Sabbatean-Frankist thought, deliberate sin—especially sexual—retrieves divine sparks, advances cosmic tikkun, and achieves redemption. Decadence becomes a sacred necessity. Epstein's operation, while lacking explicit theology, functioned similarly on a secular level: orchestrated sexual exploitation of the vulnerable bound powerful participants in complicity, generating leverage for influence, protection, and control. Shared guilt and blackmail mirrored the mutual entrapment of ritual transgression in historical sects. Both phenomena feature elite insularity shielding depravity—rabbis and authorities condemning Zevi yet unable to fully suppress the movement; institutions overlooking Epstein's red flags for years. The central figure's dramatic fall (Zevi's conversion, Epstein's custody death) left lingering structures and unanswered questions about wider involvement.
The Sick Ideology of Continuation
What unites these cases is an underlying ideology that normalizes decadence as instrumental. Sabbateanism/Frankism survived as a heretical sect by justifying boundary-breaking as redemptive, creating crypto-networks that outlived public scandal. Epstein's network, sustained by power and secrecy, reflects a continuation of the same logic in secular form: moral inversion for gain, where descent into exploitation secures dominance. No direct historical link exists—Epstein's crimes were criminal opportunism, not Kabbalistic heresy—but the pattern recurs: insulated elites using organized transgression to consolidate power, eroding norms while claiming a "greater purpose" (spiritual or pragmatic). Victims suffer, while mechanisms of protection endure.
Broader Reflection on Decadence and Sectarian Legacy
These parallels highlight how ideologies of redemption through sin foster decadence that outlives individuals. Sabbatean-Frankist antinomianism influenced fringe Jewish mysticism and indirectly broader cultural rebellions against tradition. Epstein's case exposes similar dynamics in modern elite spheres: exploitation masked as networking, impunity through influence, and cultural normalization of once-taboo behaviors. The "sick ideology" persists not as a formal sect but as a recurring temptation—when power insulates transgression, decadence becomes self-justifying, promising salvation or supremacy through moral abyss. History shows such patterns rarely vanish; they adapt, endure in shadows, and resurface when conditions allow.
The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of DotDotNews.
Read more articles by Angelo Giuliano:
Opinion | The Great Misdirection: An Extramarital Encounter vs. an Empire of Raped Children
Opinion | America's desperate dash to grab critical minerals before it's too late
Comment